A song of Ice and fire discussion (spoilers incl A Dance with Dragons)

['thul]

Ok, a theory these beings wonder what others think about (for those having read ADWD):

Spoiler

Have any of you pondered more about Jon Snow's parentage? Could it be that he is not truly a son of Eddard Stark?
Might it be that he is instead a Son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen?

He's still a Stark that way, so his Starkish look is not in doubt, and there is only one man's word that he is Eddard's son. . Lyanna forced a promise out of Eddard before dying, yet the words of the promise are unknown, as is the reason she was dying. Dying while protected by no less than three members of the kingsguard.

Well, there is another that knows of the promise, but he is Eddard's sworn bannerman and is fairly likely to be the one to reveal the truth.

Should the birthright described above be true, even Daenerys claim to the throne will be false, since she's not in the direct line of eldest children.


Now what do you think?